Tories to cut off inmate pensions

The Government apologizes for any inconvenience caused by the upcoming prison riots...

Now if they just do something about the frivolous lawsuits that far exceed the taxpayer burden that the pensions presented.
 
Excellent.

Now, when they get out and have no money at all with which to reintegrate into society, (even the meagre amounts accumulated from pensions) they can turn back to crime right away.

Sometimes you need to look beyond the immediate need to punish and try to understand longer term effects of poverty and crime.
 
Excellent point, I agree


Excellent.

Now, when they get out and have no money at all with which to reintegrate into society, (even the meagre amounts accumulated from pensions) they can turn back to crime right away.

Sometimes you need to look beyond the immediate need to punish and try to understand longer term effects of poverty and crime.
 
Excellent.

Now, when they get out and have no money at all with which to reintegrate into society, (even the meagre amounts accumulated from pensions) they can turn back to crime right away.

Sometimes you need to look beyond the immediate need to punish and try to understand longer term effects of poverty and crime.

Apparantly the pension removal is for permanent residents only, on a tax back basis. Actually I think the pension funds should be credited to the prison system in order to offset the cost of the room, board medical and dental services. But again thats just me
 
At first, before I had my second cup of coffee, I read it too fast and thought they were going to cut something else off. Just sayin'.
 
Now, when they get out and have no money at all with which to reintegrate into society, (even the meagre amounts accumulated from pensions) they can turn back to crime right away.

Not true. When they get out they'll have their pensions. Just not back-pay. What do they need the back-pay for? If they're collecting a pension they are retired.

The Conservatives may do a lot of stupid things, but this is not one of them.
 
Typical Stevie, all about the headline, nothing substantive, and I have no doubt has put zero thought into the legality/practicality/humanity (not everyone who's going too be affected by this is Clifford Olsen)/precedent (who do they take pensions from next) and anything beyond feeling good in the moment of doing it.
 
Do these senior citizen prisoners still retain their constitutional right to vote for a government of their choice?
 
Excellent.

Now, when they get out and have no money at all with which to reintegrate into society, (even the meagre amounts accumulated from pensions) they can turn back to crime right away.

Sometimes you need to look beyond the immediate need to punish and try to understand longer term effects of poverty and crime.

So let them keep their pensions but charge them room and board if they have any independent source of income. Then they still have the pension when they get out.
 
You're all in such a hurry to condemn them that you miss the point - they still have rights, and they need to be ablr to reintegrate someday. Imprisonment is their punishment, and they pay their debts. They still ahve rights. I guess this is a moot point, since the Tories have sided with the mob, but I think that released felons need to be able to get their lives back once they're out, and forcing them right into poverty is not going to help that.
 
Precisely the point...

I think that released felons need to be able to get their lives back once they're out, and forcing them right into poverty is not going to help that.

Which they can do when THEY ARE OUT.

Once they are convicted of a crime, they should lose all but their basic human rights if I had my way. "Rights" should be earned as productive law abiding members of society, not given automatically. Lets talk about responsibility instead for a change.

Just my nickels worth.
 
Last edited:
Wait a minute. You lose some rights when you go to prison, but not all rights, and the government
cannot take away prisoners rights willy-nilly.
 
The purpose of OAS/GIS is to provide everyone with a certain minimum standard of living in their old age. Prisoners already get room and board from the state while they are in prison. Once they get out, their pension payments can resume and they can live at that minimum standard like everyone else. Paying them OAS/GIS while in prison essentially means paying TWICE for their room and board.

I see no benefit and no value and no justice or even sense in allowing them to save up OAS/GIS payments that they don't need while in prison, so that they can retire rich when they get out.

Maybe you will want to argue that OAS/GIS does not provide an acceptable minimum standard of living, but in that case, let's fix it for the non-criminals first. Saying that a criminal should live a state funded life of luxury on "retirement" from prison, while someone who never committed a crime should suffer in poverty is just wrong.
 
Precisely the point...



Which they can do when THEY ARE OUT.

Once they are convicted of a crime, they lose all but their basic human rights if I had my way. "Rights" should be earned as productive law abiding members of society, not given automatically. Lets talk about responsibility instead for a change.

Just my nickels worth.


That's why redneck like you don't actually set policy.

I don't have to 'earn' my rights by behaving the way Cycleguy likes - they are innate to the human being according to the Charter. It takes a certain strength of character to defend the rights of those you don't approve of, but it must be done, or else you get a totalitarian state.
 
Wait a minute. You lose some rights when you go to prison, but not all rights, and the government
cannot take away prisoners rights willy-nilly.

Maybe they should hold it for him in an special account for him so he can draw on it when he gets out.
 
That's why redneck like you don't actually set policy.

I don't have to 'earn' my rights by behaving the way Cycleguy likes - they are innate to the human being according to the Charter. It takes a certain strength of character to defend the rights of those you don't approve of, but it must be done, or else you get a totalitarian state.

Are you saying that being paid money by your government is somehow a human right? I suspect there are several billion people who think you're wrong.
 
Are you saying that being paid money by your government is somehow a human right? I suspect there are several billion people who think you're wrong.

I cannot speek for hangman, but it is a fact that only a few specific rights are taken away from
someone who is sent to prison. The right to go wherever you want, most importantly.

The simple solution to the (very minor) problem of inmates receiving OAS, would be to charge
all inmates with income (from OAS, private pensions, CPP, interest, dividends, fees for newspaper
articles(black) etc. ) a fee for room and board.