Bill Cosby speaks up again. Interesting

happygrump said:
Wow... powerful stuff. I'm just afraid of how the "politically correct" crowd is going to take all this.

They're going to bend over and take it since he's a black man.

They won't be able to paint him as another racist whitey this time...

Cheers,

-djk
 
So is a person a racist if they're African American speaking out about African Americans?

Sometimes the truth is obvious, but; nobody wants to say it in fear of being tagged a racist.
 
He's dead on!

It is about time that someone from the black community spoke up and said that. We have standards as a community, not just black vs white, that define how we communicate with each other. Proper english signifies education. If you can't string a proper sentence together then how is someone else going to receive that information? Not well I would gather.

We all, regardless of colour, have to rise above the circumstances in which we find ourselves. I hope that is the message that gets heard.

Also interesting are the reults of the poll. Of 170,000 votes cast, 98% agree with Mr. Cosby.

Well done, Bill.

SQ.
 
healer677 said:
So is a person a racist if they're African American speaking out about African Americans?

Sometimes the truth is obvious, but; nobody wants to say it in fear of being tagged a racist.

I don't think so, but sometimes a message connects better when it comes from someone of your own group.

SQ
 
superquad1968 said:
I don't think so, but sometimes a message connects better when it comes from someone of your own group.

SQ

I agree Bill Cosby is someone that is not afraid to speak up. His words hopefully will empower blacks to do better.

To me he seems like a role model!

Well said Bill!
 
Its called tough love and sometimes what you don't want to hear is what you need to hear. Kudos to you Bill. --- Kev
 
Winston said:
Sooner or later, the black community will lable Bill an "oreo"

Either that or "white washed", "sell-out" and other even less polite terms like they do with Colin Powell.
 
The way I look at it......


The Chinese were brought to North America to build the railroads - in almost slavery conditions. The Japanese were interred in WW2 - most lost their livelihood. The Irish, Italians and western European immigrants worked like dogs to make a better life, establish nice neighborhood then moved to the suburbs.

SO...

In general, LIFE SUCKS, WEAR A HELMET!

You can only use slavery as an excuse for so long. Affirmative action should have evened that score a long time ago. We don't give any of the other ethnic groups all those breaks. Enough is enough. I'm sick of hearing people like Sharpton, Farrakhan and that local Toronto puke Dudley Lawes.

DO what you have to do to make life better for yourself and your family. Go to school - its free in Canada (at least finish high school), get a job - dont rely on social services to make your life better, and for Gods sake. When you make a bit of money - spend it wisely.
NO, NO, NO - you dont need a Lexus or Escalade if you make 30k a year. If your rims or stereo cost more than your car - well guess what?
 
Lees' prevoius thread on culture addresses this issue vary well.

It's just now, a prominent African American celebrity is not just making a social commentary - he, in his opinion is stating the facts as he views it.
 
healer677 said:
…edit…You can only use slavery as an excuse for so long. Affirmative action should have evened that score a long time ago. We don't give any of the other ethnic groups all those breaks.…edit…
All what breaks? For who? If you're speaking about the US, where there are official policies directed towards African Americans, you should say so. I'm not aware of such in Canada—it is a Toronto board—but perhaps you can enlighten me healer.
As to using slavery as an "excuse": it lasted for more than a few centuries and we (again, your reference is American) have had affirmative action for less than 40 years. Perhaps, as you say, it should have evened the score. Clearly it didn't.
Life is yours to do what you can, but pointing fingers at your fellows because they're having troubles helps no one.
 
Viktor Frankl, the psychiatrist who survived Auscwitz and chronicled his experiences there in Man's Search for Meaning, wanted to see a Statue of Responsibility on the West Coast, to provide a counterpoint to the Statue of Liberty in New York. His point, as I see it, is that liberty comes at a price. That price is the responsibility to do the best you can, regardless of exterior circumstances.

I think that the Cos is trying to echo Frankl's point. Taking responsibility for our lives means sometimes doing the hard things and not going along with the crowd. It means hard work without handouts. It means that the prize comes only after it has been earned.


Also, remember that the Cos lost a son as a result of a botched car robbery.
 
happygrump said:
Viktor Frankl, the psychiatrist who survived Auscwitz and chronicled his experiences there in Man's Search for Meaning, wanted to see a Statue of Responsibility on the West Coast, to provide a counterpoint to the Statue of Liberty in New York. His point, as I see it, is that liberty comes at a price. That price is the responsibility to do the best you can, regardless of exterior circumstances.
Actually the Statue of Responsibility could happen. It's proposed for the new San Pedro waterfront in Calif.
http://experts.uli.org/Content/AdServices/News/News_Archive_03/News_018.htm
"In a separate presentation, a 333-foot-tall Statue of Responsibility was proposed to be built with related developments on 15 acres at the end of the southern peninsula entry to the harbor where ships enter Los Angeles Harbor. It would be designed to complement the East Coast's Statue of Liberty.
The sculpture depicts four 'magnificent behemoth figures depicting all of humanity, arms intertwined and wrapped protectively around the planet,' states the written proposal.
'The statue's inspired figures of humankind sit atop the tree of life, its roots going down deep in the ocean's floor, to symbolically connect with the entire planet,' according to the written proposal.
The entire project is estimated to cost $200 million, to be raised through the nonprofit Monument of Responsibility and Learning Center."

I think it would a great addition to the American philosophy, because with freedom comes responsibility. And responsibility is something America seems to lack.
Happy Independence day
 
Hey, I'm as politically correct as anyone, but I find myself in total agreement with Cosby, and give him all the credit (props!) for saying it out loud.

But as someone else pointed out, this ain't a black thing, or an American black thing. We are raising a generation of illiterate fools right here in Canada — black and white - thanks to a gutted educational system. And these are the ones who will be screwing up until they smarten up, and we'll all be paying the cost....

Maybe those right wing folks who want to pay less taxes (and taxes pay for schools as well as health care and clean cities) will carry some of the blame.
 
Muddy said:
...edit...

Maybe those right wing folks who want to pay less taxes (and taxes pay for schools as well as health care and clean cities) will carry some of the blame.

Nice Try! This has less to do with left vs right then it does with how specifically the blacks, but in general those "less advantaged", treat themselves. My take on Cosby's words are that they look for others to blame to make their situation acceptable. It's NOT always someone else's fault.

It does not matter how "gutted" the educational system is because these kids don't want to go. You could have the best educational system in the world and throw massive amounts of money into it and it wouldn't change the situation.

The leftist argument does not fit this argument. Wrong cause to the effect. The solution lies only within. They have to pick themselves up. No other party can do this for them.

Until they realize it, their plight will remain the same.

SQ
 
superquad1968 said:
It does not matter how "gutted" the educational system is because these kids don't want to go. You could have the best educational system in the world and throw massive amounts of money into it and it wouldn't change the situation.
Nonsense.
An educational system where the teachers, students, curriculum and administrators are valued will create an atmosphere where students want to participate and learn. Anything less is setting ourselves up for an abyssmal future.

Trashing a system for the short-term goal of some minor money savings is about as short-sighted a thing as I've ever seen.

The contention of the right-wing that market forces should be the only set of standards that are of value is patently ludicrous. We're witnessing the result right now.
 
HappyGrump,

I am not getting into the argument.

What I am saying is that the words Cosby spoke about vis-a-vis the black situation would not be affected by the amount of money in the system. Irrelevant if managers are valued, etc. Kids of this type (which is to say not all) couldn't care less if the school had top of the line computers, the best gym, the highest paid teachers, etc. They just don't want to go.

Which leads into Cosby's hypothesis that the only people who can help the disadvantaged are the disadvantaged. You have to pull yourself up. There are enough programs in place that provide the framework. So if you want to further yourself then there are safeguards and incentives in place.

Too many of us have completely forgotten about the principle of self-responsibility. We blame others for our plight.

Your argument about lack of funding may be valid or not. However in this context that particular argument is irrelevant. In this instance there is no correlation. People will use that argument to further their own agenda.

SQ
 
SQ;

I certainly agree with your statement that, "Too many of us have completely forgotten about the principle of self-responsibility," hence my post about Frankl's idea of a Statue of Responsibility (see above). I think where you and I may disagree is that I believe the idea that self-responsibility - or, in this case, lack of it - is a symptom of a much larger social problem and not an illness unto itself. Perhaps I'm wrong, though.

It's always been my contention that a failure of a child in the school system is a failure of the teacher, the school itself, the school board and the curriculum. The child does not fail the class, the class fails the child. Mind you, this doesn't win me any points among my teacher friends... but maybe that's another story for another time.

But on the larger issue of inclusion of everyone in society - regardless of colour, race, nationality, etc. etc. - it seems pretty clear that you and I are on the same page. So-called downtrodden segments of society do not do themselves any favours by turning to crime, drugs and violence.