You be the judge, motorist kills bicylist - You know the facts - render your decision

Ceiling Cat

Well-known member
Feb 25, 2009
30,289
2,695
113
The fact that the bicylist had previous warrants for theft and uttering forged documents do not have a bearing on this case, nor the fact that the motorist was previously the Attourney General of Ontatio do not alter the facts of this case.

A collision between the bicylist and motorist and an arguement ensues. The bicylist climbs on to the automobile and in a threatening manner to menace the morotist. The motorist panics and drives down a the street at times on the wrong side for approx 100 meters The bicylist stikes a telephone pole and a mail box and is dislodged and crushed under the wheels of the vehicle.

The bicylist must bear the bulk of blame in this tragic matter, he escalated the situation by climbing on to the vehicle and menacing the driver. The driver is not blamless in this matter, it may be panic that cause him to drive away with the bicylist on the hood of the car.

Decision,

The motorist carries some but not all of the blame in this case, but it is cyclist that must take the mojority of blame. To climb on to a car and threaten the driver did cause him to panic and not think properly. The cyclist is in great part the author of his own demise

Justice C. Cats
 
The difference is that you get to be the judge in this one.:o
 
Cyclist has paid the ultimate price, death. The motorist's response was drampatic, perhaps way more than should have been done. It takes two to make this death occur, it takes two to tango. One paid the ultimate price, the other is likely guilty of manslaughter.
 
Ceiling Cat said:
The difference is that you get to be the judge in this one.:o
Okay then. 3,500 lb car hits/confrontation with 20 lb cycle. Driver's fault.

Cyclist overeacts hits car. Cyclist's fault.

Driver is scared and tries to leave scene. Not an unreasonable response.

Cyclist grabs onto car possibly trying to hit driver or hanging on for dear life. Cyclist's fault if trying to hit driver or driver's fault if cyclist wasn't trying to hit him.

Driver tries to escape. Reasonable response.

Driver crosses into oncoming lane and smashes cyclist into object(s). Driver's fault, this is very bad.

Cyclist laying road injured, driver continues and doesn't help. Driver's fault, this is very bad.


Decision

Driver is guilty of negligent homicide/manslaughter. Take Cyclist's actions into account when sentencing.
 
Big Michael said:
Driver crosses into oncoming lane and smashes cyclist into object(s). Driver's fault, this is very bad.
.

Actually some reports, and I guess some forensic investigation will show that some are claimign that the cyclist had his hands on the wheel which could be the cause ot the lane change.

Big Michael said:
Cyclist laying road injured, driver continues and doesn't help. Driver's fault, this is very bad..

Driver pulled into the closest "driveway" and awaited police (some reports are that he also called 911)

Still too many unknown facts for anyone to be able to judge this.
 
masterchief said:
Still too many unknown facts for anyone to be able to judge this.

Agreed, and unfortunately we will not fully get one side of the story.
Other than the unnecessary loss of life, my only issue with this affair is that the former A-G wasn't given a bail hearing or a breathalyzer. There appears to be some favouritism.
 
I suppose because it is in large red letters that makes it final lol!! Of course we don't have all the evidence so at this point it is just speculation.
 
A great lawyer like him why couldn't he talk the cyclist down, or take control of the situation.

Good to see lawyers, especially one that was the AG in this situation. They are so quick to analyse what victims, cops, crooks do in a second or so and debate it for hours.
Now the shoe is on the other foot...
 
Keep in mind the motorist wasn't drinking, but the cyclist had been. As well, earlier in the evening the cyclist was involved in an instance with a homeless man that caused the police to be called and said cyclist was put in the back of the cop car before being released.

If he was inebriated, and anger levels already raised due to the earlier altercation, he certainly wasn't in his right mind when he lurched at the car and grabbed the steering wheel. He was the aggressor.
 
Not sure about how much jail time---if any--but he should not get his drivers license back for a long time--if ever. He used his car as a weapon.


Now what will really happen in court...he likely cope a peal on a very low charge and not lose his drivers license for one day :(
 
Big Michael said:
Cyclist laying road injured, driver continues and doesn't help. Driver's fault, this is very bad.

Driver pulled over and called 911 after cyclist was removed from his car. Unless you know that the driver is qualified to perform first aid what more can he be expected to do? I don't think many of us would be willing to go back and give aid to a person who was just trying/threatening to do us grievous harm....
 
As usual, lots of terbites sittting in their armchairs and talking righteous talk.

I'm not sure how I would react. If somebody is hanging on the side of my car, screaming obscenities and threatening to effing kick my face in (I know, that's an assumption but probably what happened), I don't think I would stop the car, ask him politely to wait just a minute while I pull out my cellphone, make a call and then sit back and wait for the nutbar to pull out his gun and shoot.

And I don't think any of you would either if you weren't being so politically correct...
 
ray liotta said:
A great lawyer like him why couldn't he talk the cyclist down, or take control of the situation.

Good to see lawyers, especially one that was the AG in this situation. They are so quick to analyse what victims, cops, crooks do in a second or so and debate it for hours.
Now the shoe is on the other foot...
You really don't believe a fair number of us think about this?
 
S.C. Joe said:
Not sure about how much jail time---if any--but he should not get his drivers license back for a long time--if ever. He used his car as a weapon.(
We honestly don't know yet S.C. Joe.

Perhaps he behaved like a jerk, then again perhaps he behaved in a very rational manner.

I'm seeing news articles all over the place - I don't believe it is yet possible to make any sort of rational judgement.
 
Big Michael said:
Decision

Driver is guilty of negligent homicide/manslaughter. Take Cyclist's actions into account when sentencing.

Nice summary.
 
evilsgood said:
If he was inebriated, and anger levels already raised due to the earlier altercation, he certainly wasn't in his right mind when he lurched at the car and grabbed the steering wheel. He was the aggressor.

I have ridden a bike after drinking a moderate amount. It is very difficult. He would have to have mad skillz to drive while inebriated in my opinion.

As for the aggressor, reports are the driver hit the cyclist first and tried to flee. I expect both were being dickheads.
 
Big Michael said:
my only issue with this affair is that the former A-G wasn't given a bail hearing or a breathalyzer.

Well if there were signs of intoxication, he would have been given a sobriety test at the station. There were no reports of any hint of the driver being under the influence.

He's a high profile public person, his spouse is an agent of the courts....where is the risk that would require any bond to be posted for thier release? A bail hearing would be a waste of the courts time and the taxpayers money.
 
Garrett said:
I have ridden a bike after drinking a moderate amount. It is very difficult. He would have to have mad skillz to drive while inebriated in my opinion.

As for the aggressor, reports are the driver hit the cyclist first and tried to flee. I expect both were being dickheads.

Nope, every report or eyewitness account I have seen or read about said that the bike ran into the saab.

rubmeister100 said:
Video shows that BOTH the normal westbound lanes of Bloor were blocked by a work crew, truck and pylons.

So where did the driver have left to drive away?

Now that this fact has come to light I suppose that the predictible ones are now going to say that Bryant was SOOOOO determined to kill the cyclist that he drove into oncoming traffic to kill the guy.

More facts are likely to come to light.

On CTV late news tonight they were insinuating that the police might have been premature in their charging Bryant. As new evidence comes to light they might drop the charges. But I saw the video that showed the lanes blocked so in actuality it was only a 2 lane road, not 4 like it normally is.