Ok - long post: here is my confessional/experience with Internet dating sites. I suspect that many married/divorced guys on Terb may relate.
Background: I was married for over 20 years. My ex-wife was very attractive, aged better than me (helped by plastic surgery/botox/fake tits), and loved sex. So what was the problem? Me. I went one year before cheating. I was not good at monogamy and used hobbying as a safe, harm free way to satisfy a need. I loved my wife for many years, was a good husband in every other respect and a good, devoted Dad for our kids. But I was shitty at the faithful husband aspect. I worked in a high stress job and felt that I needed, deserved and had earned a stress relief - quick, mid-day or after work sex was it. Sometimes 2 or 3 times a week. Fast forward to the present. Any mid-50's guy can relate to the fact that when you look in the mirror or get together with buddies or admire woman you are NOT doing this with the mindset of a 50 something. In fact, when I get together with buddies - we joke around and act like the same idiots we were over 35 years ago. Except now we're dirty old men. In sports its the same thing - My body is older but my brain doesn't know it. Last year, I bought something from Shoppers and the girl gave me the Seniors discount without me asking. It was an eye-opener!!
All of this delusion/denial relates to my internet dating experience. I tried Match and PoF for a while - maybe a year during the separation/divorce. Immediately the problem surfaced that most of the women I would automatically look twice at were looking for men at least 10 - 20 years younger than me. There were women in my age cohort who were attractive but these were few and far between - that's how shallow I am... LOL. And all the inquiries I received were from women roughly my age - oddly enough, there were no 20 something bombshells looking for a past-middle-aged guy with a body type "average" (which means a few extra pounds). [Actually that's not completely true. I got 3 or 4 inquiries from young women who looked like models. Gorgeous!! Problem is, they all lived in the US, but were moving to Toronto in the near future and happened to stumble upon my profile. They ALL wanted to meet me and if I wanted to see them for a weekend I just had to send money for their plane ticket!!!! LOL!] Anyway, went on many dates and some were awkward disappointments and a few worked out for repeat dates. My first civilian make-out session after 20 plus years of marriage was super-awkward - my ex-wife and I knew each other so well that we had a sort of natural rhythm. And again, the shallow things bothered me. Even though I'm probably 10 - 15 pounds overweight myself - I don't like to see a loose belly, or cellulite in a woman (talk about a double standard). So there were a couple times where intimacy was a problem even when I found them attractive in clothing. And as pathetic as it sounds - I even faked ED once. In that sense, hobbying may have spoiled me forever. Anyway, long story short after meeting maybe 8 - 9 different women, only 1 worked out where there was a true mutual attraction and we got along for what might have been a longer term thing. Meanwhile, I continued to hobby, and kind of blew it on purpose by neglecting to call for an extended period. Now I'm taking a break. Net net, hobbying is cheaper and sexually way more satisfying. Maybe I'll mature one day.
As far as comparisons go (and I think both Match and PoF are owned by the same parent) - I found that Match has more dishonest profiles and people who use way out of date pictures. And some real whacko's - too. PoF seemed to have more genuine, down to earth women looking for relationships - so is less flash and more desperation. The search engine is far from perfect. Eg: I would receive matches that matched MY criteria but I would not necessarily match theirs. So that wastes time. I had more dates from Match but quickly learned that: Ages are generally fudged. Body type is too. "Athletic and toned" usually means "average" and "average" usually means "a few extra pounds". And claims to be "happily divorced" is bullshit. Every women I met bitched about their ex in some way. I found the "hit" ratio to be about 5 to one when responding to a profile and out of that - 5 hits may result in a one date. So it's like any sales effort - lots of misses and you need a thick skin and you can't be afraid of rejection and failure. And you'll see many of the same profiles being recycled with new stories and the same pictures - people adjust their profiles based upon response - I did the same thing. So somebody you passed on earlier, may show up again in your matches.
Oh and funny story: Early on when I had just joined Match - I was browsing and came upon a vaguely familiar face who was a former friend from my high school who was now divorced and who (according to her profile age) must have been 6 years old when we were in grade 13 together. I sent her a message and we had a good laugh and actually met for coffee to trade stories. She had some horror stories - I think women get scammed on these sites far more than men. Normally I would have asked her out for a date - but man, did we feel and look old!!