The Republicans' Plan to Stop Mass Shootings: Nothing
Right-Wing Talking Heads Are Smearing the Parkland Survivors
Some are claiming the kids are leftist pawns or even "crisis actors" who faked the whole thing.
Eve Peyser
Feb 21 2018, 5:50pm
On Valentine's Day, a gunman opened fire at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland, Florida, killing 17 of his former classmates and teachers. In the week following the shooting, Parkland students have demanded legislation that could prevent future tragedies, becoming spokespeople for the gun control movement overnight.
"If all our president and government can do is send 'thoughts and prayers,' then it's time for victims to be the change we need to see," said Emma Gonzalez, a Stoneman student, in a teary speech last week. "They say that tougher gun laws do not decrease gun violence—we call BS!"
Obviously, the majority of right-wing politicians and media personalities are not going to be convinced that assault weapons need to be banned by either the shooting or its aftermath. But surely they would be respectful to teenagers who had just watched their classmates get murdered, right? Nope! While some GOP figures like Florida Senator Marco Rubio have been relatively restrained, some right-wing media websites and personalities and tried to discredit the Parkland shooting victims as "false flags" and "crisis actors," taking a note from the Alex Jones's playbook—the unhinged InfoWars host famous for being a Sandy Hook truther, among other things.
On Wednesday, a video claiming David Hogg, a Stoneman senior, was an actor "bought and paid by CNN and George Soros" was the number-one trending video on YouTube until the video platform took it down after the media noticed. On Tuesday, the president's eldest son, Donald Jr., was caught liking two tweets that pushed the same BS conspiracy theory about Hogg.
“I’m not a crisis actor,” Hogg told Anderson Cooper on CNN. “I’m someone who had to witness this and live through this and I continue to be having to do that.”
Here are the right wingers who have attacked its student survivors:
The Gateway Pundit
On Tuesday, Lucian Wintrich, the "D.C. Bureau Chief & White House Correspondent" for the Gateway Pundit, a particularly toxic conservative blog known for propagating hoaxes and its exceptional disregard for what's actually true, penned a post headlined "EXPOSED: School Shooting Survivor Turned Activist David Hogg’s Father in FBI, Appears To Have Been Coached On Anti-Trump Lines." Wintrich accused Hogg being "heavily coached on lines" and "merely reciting a script," using the fact that his father works for the FBI as evidence that he's part of a larger mainstream media conspiracy to push the "anti-Conservative/anti-Trump narrative."
Later on Tuesday, Wintrich published another post, this one headlined, "Exclusive: Soros-Linked Organizers of 'Women’s March' Selected Anti-Trump Kids to Be Face of Parkland Tragedy – And Excluded Pro-Trump Kids," which cites an anonymous source the Gateway Pundit claims is the father of a shooting victim, and goes on to find sinister implications in the fact that these students are drama kids.
"These children are being used as political tools by the far left to further anti-Conservative rhetoric and an anti-gun agenda," Wintrich wrote. "The students at the forefront of this agenda were all peers of his child, they were all members of the same drama club at their high school. This fact was verified and confirmed by Buzzfeed who sent a reporter to visit the student activists at their “command center” at one of their homes. Buzzfeed reported on, but left unexplored, the fact that these students are theater-trained."
InfoWars
Not to be outdone by the Gateway Pundit, Alex Jones's InfoWars has pushed a number of false theories about the Parkland shooting. As reported by the New York Times, Jones "suggested that the mass shooting was a 'false flag' orchestrated by anti-gun groups."
An article with the headline, "STUDENT ANTI-GUN ACTIVIST FEATURED IN CBS NEWS STORY – SIX MONTHS AGO" that was written by Dan Lyman, the "InfoWars/NewsWars foreign correspondent," tries to discredit Hogg's newfound role as an anti-gun activist by pointing out that he appeared in a local CBS news report six months ago. It also mentions the same video the Gateway Pundit video used, which Lyman claims "appears to show Hogg being walked through rehearsed lines in an interview after the shooting."
InfoWars has published many conspiratorial articles about the shooting in the last week—accusing liberals of "exploit[ing] the tragic event, as they often do, by voicing their disdain for the Second Amendment," blaming antidepressants for the tragedy, and arguing that there was a secret second shooter in the attack.
Rush Limbaugh
The conservative radio host, whose program draws about 13 million listeners per week, went after Parkland survivors in his broadcast, asserting: “Everything they’re doing is right out of the Democrat Party’s various playbooks. It has the same enemies: the NRA and guns.”
Fox News
The conservative cable news network hasn't gone after students like Gonzalez and Hogg as vigorously as its more conspiratorial counterparts have. An op-ed published Tuesday on FoxNews.com, however, asserted, "The mainstream media is cynically using a lot of traumatized teens from Parkland, Fla., in their latest shameful attack on President Trump and the National Rifle Association."
"It's right out of the pages of 'Rules for Radicals,'" complained author Todd Starnes in a passage that sounds like a right-wing version of Mad Libs. "Turning innocent children into propaganda pawns to peddle a fake news narrative."
Dinesh D'Souza
The right-wing activist, convicted felon, and National Review contributor, whose latest book accuses the American left of having roots in Nazism, had some astonishingly unkind words for the Parkland survivors.
"Worst news since their parents told them to get summer jobs," D'Souza commented on a photo of Parkland survivors crying after Florida lawmakers declined to vote on a bill banning assault rifles.
"Adults 1, kids 0," he also wrote in response to the same news.
Ted Nugent
On his Facebook page, which has almost 3.5 million likes, the right-wing activist and music dude posted a link to an article from Natural News—which purports to be "the world's top news source on natural health"—headlined, "It’s all THEATER: Florida high school shooting survivor caught on video rehearsing scripted lines, coached by camera man," which is an aggregation of Wintrich's Gateway Pundit story.
Bill O'Reilly
The former Fox News host, who was fired after multiple allegations of sexual harassment and once paid $32 million to settle a sexual harassment lawsuit, didn't go as far as D'Souza or the Gateway Pundit, but echoed the idea that the surviving students are leftist pawns on Twitter and "debated" the topic on his personal website.
David Clarke
The former Milwaukee sheriff, who was once investigated by the FBI for sending his officers after a guy who got into an argument with him on a plane and on whose watch a mentally ill jail inmate died of dehydration, is another right-wing talking head being an asshole to the teenage mass shooting survivors. According to Media Matters, Clarke was on something called the Joe Pags Show on Monday, which began with host Joe Pagliarulo opining that Gonzalez “a far-lefty propagandist—well, I don’t know that she’s a propagandist... Maybe her parents are, maybe the community is." Later in the program, Clarke said, “My dad would have backhanded me” for “popping off” against an authority figure like President Trump.
It's worth noting that Clarke spent years popping off against Barack Obama, but it's not like calling him—or any of people on this list—out for hypocrisy is particularly useful.
https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/bj5yqw/rush-limbaugh-ted-nugent-parkland
The #1 Trending Video on YouTube Right Now Suggests That a Student From the Parkland Shooting Is a Crisis Actor
A video described as 'DAVID HOGG THE ACTOR….' has made the top of the trending section, another example that YouTube has a conspiracy theory problem.
Emanuel Maiberg
Feb 21 2018, 8:32am
Update: YouTube has removed the video about three hours after this article was first published. It had more than 200,000 views at the time. Other videos from the same YouTube user spreading the same conspiracy theory are still live on YouTube.
A YouTube spokesperson sent us the following statement:
"This video should never have appeared in Trending. Because the video contained footage from an authoritative news source, our system misclassified it. As soon as we became aware of the video, we removed it from Trending and from YouTube for violating our policies. We are working to improve our systems moving forward."
It's a vile conspiracy theory we might expect from the host of Inforwars Alex Jones, but right now it is the number one trending video on YouTube.
The conspiracy theory is that some of the students who are speaking out against the lax gun control laws that enabled the mass shooting that killed 17 of their peers at a Parkland, Florida high school last week are not who they say they are. They are "crisis actors," paid performers funded by familiar boogeymen like George Soros to vilify gun ownership and dismantle the Second Amendment.
This is not true, but it's what the most popular video on YouTube, which at the time of writing has 174,000 views, suggests. In the video, David Hogg, one of the more outspoken Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School students who has made several television appearances since the shooting, is seen in a CBS 2 Los Angeles news report. The report details the events of a video Hogg took and that went viral in 2017. It shows one of Hogg's friends, another teenager, confronting an overzealous lifeguard. Here's the video on CBS's YouTube page, and Hogg's original upload.
The only description on the video is "DAVID HOGG THE ACTOR…." and many of the comments go on to accuse Hogg of being an actor "bought and paid by CNN and George Soros." Mike m, the YouTube user who uploaded this trending video also uploaded a video titled "David Hogg Can't Remember His Lines When Interviewed for Florida school shooting." The description to that video reads: "Ask yourself why is he practicing his lines...??? ???" This user also uploaded videos that cover familiar conspiracy theories like chemtrails and UFOs.
As Hogg explained to CNN, his family moved from California to Florida several years ago and he joined Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School for its TV production program. He took the video of the lifeguard while visiting friends in Los Angeles.
It’s a coincidence that some random person in a local news report will go viral on YouTube and then make national news for vastly different reasons, but it happens. I'm still trying to wrap my brain around the fact that George Lindell, the subject of the autotuned viral video "Reality Hits You Hard Bro" also went viral in 2016 for yelling "Jew-S-A" at a press pen at a Trump rally, but it's true. Life is weird and full of coincidences. Things that seem very unlikely, like, say, landing on the moon, actually happen. It's true.
It's not surprising but still shameful that this trending video is one of many on YouTube. If you watch it, YouTube is likely to offer you videos that claim to show Hogg "forgetting his lines" while speaking to CNN, "SICK secrets about the shooting," and other lies right-wing media uses to muddy the waters around the issue of gun control.
It's only been a month since YouTube was in hot water over its trending videos, which previously highlighted a Logan Paul video that featured a man who took his own life in the thumbnail. As Wired noted at the time, that should have been a moment of reckoning for YouTube, but the trending Hogg video shows that it learned nothing.
Update: When this article was first published the YouTube video suggesting David Hogg is a crisis actor was the number two trending video on YouTube. It is now the number one trending video on YouTube.
https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/mb5p4y/youtube-david-hogg-parkland-shooting-conspiracy-theory
Right-Wing Talking Heads Are Smearing the Parkland Survivors
Some are claiming the kids are leftist pawns or even "crisis actors" who faked the whole thing.
Eve Peyser
Feb 21 2018, 5:50pm
On Valentine's Day, a gunman opened fire at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland, Florida, killing 17 of his former classmates and teachers. In the week following the shooting, Parkland students have demanded legislation that could prevent future tragedies, becoming spokespeople for the gun control movement overnight.
"If all our president and government can do is send 'thoughts and prayers,' then it's time for victims to be the change we need to see," said Emma Gonzalez, a Stoneman student, in a teary speech last week. "They say that tougher gun laws do not decrease gun violence—we call BS!"
Obviously, the majority of right-wing politicians and media personalities are not going to be convinced that assault weapons need to be banned by either the shooting or its aftermath. But surely they would be respectful to teenagers who had just watched their classmates get murdered, right? Nope! While some GOP figures like Florida Senator Marco Rubio have been relatively restrained, some right-wing media websites and personalities and tried to discredit the Parkland shooting victims as "false flags" and "crisis actors," taking a note from the Alex Jones's playbook—the unhinged InfoWars host famous for being a Sandy Hook truther, among other things.
On Wednesday, a video claiming David Hogg, a Stoneman senior, was an actor "bought and paid by CNN and George Soros" was the number-one trending video on YouTube until the video platform took it down after the media noticed. On Tuesday, the president's eldest son, Donald Jr., was caught liking two tweets that pushed the same BS conspiracy theory about Hogg.
“I’m not a crisis actor,” Hogg told Anderson Cooper on CNN. “I’m someone who had to witness this and live through this and I continue to be having to do that.”
Here are the right wingers who have attacked its student survivors:
The Gateway Pundit
On Tuesday, Lucian Wintrich, the "D.C. Bureau Chief & White House Correspondent" for the Gateway Pundit, a particularly toxic conservative blog known for propagating hoaxes and its exceptional disregard for what's actually true, penned a post headlined "EXPOSED: School Shooting Survivor Turned Activist David Hogg’s Father in FBI, Appears To Have Been Coached On Anti-Trump Lines." Wintrich accused Hogg being "heavily coached on lines" and "merely reciting a script," using the fact that his father works for the FBI as evidence that he's part of a larger mainstream media conspiracy to push the "anti-Conservative/anti-Trump narrative."
Later on Tuesday, Wintrich published another post, this one headlined, "Exclusive: Soros-Linked Organizers of 'Women’s March' Selected Anti-Trump Kids to Be Face of Parkland Tragedy – And Excluded Pro-Trump Kids," which cites an anonymous source the Gateway Pundit claims is the father of a shooting victim, and goes on to find sinister implications in the fact that these students are drama kids.
"These children are being used as political tools by the far left to further anti-Conservative rhetoric and an anti-gun agenda," Wintrich wrote. "The students at the forefront of this agenda were all peers of his child, they were all members of the same drama club at their high school. This fact was verified and confirmed by Buzzfeed who sent a reporter to visit the student activists at their “command center” at one of their homes. Buzzfeed reported on, but left unexplored, the fact that these students are theater-trained."
InfoWars
Not to be outdone by the Gateway Pundit, Alex Jones's InfoWars has pushed a number of false theories about the Parkland shooting. As reported by the New York Times, Jones "suggested that the mass shooting was a 'false flag' orchestrated by anti-gun groups."
An article with the headline, "STUDENT ANTI-GUN ACTIVIST FEATURED IN CBS NEWS STORY – SIX MONTHS AGO" that was written by Dan Lyman, the "InfoWars/NewsWars foreign correspondent," tries to discredit Hogg's newfound role as an anti-gun activist by pointing out that he appeared in a local CBS news report six months ago. It also mentions the same video the Gateway Pundit video used, which Lyman claims "appears to show Hogg being walked through rehearsed lines in an interview after the shooting."
InfoWars has published many conspiratorial articles about the shooting in the last week—accusing liberals of "exploit[ing] the tragic event, as they often do, by voicing their disdain for the Second Amendment," blaming antidepressants for the tragedy, and arguing that there was a secret second shooter in the attack.
Rush Limbaugh
The conservative radio host, whose program draws about 13 million listeners per week, went after Parkland survivors in his broadcast, asserting: “Everything they’re doing is right out of the Democrat Party’s various playbooks. It has the same enemies: the NRA and guns.”
Fox News
The conservative cable news network hasn't gone after students like Gonzalez and Hogg as vigorously as its more conspiratorial counterparts have. An op-ed published Tuesday on FoxNews.com, however, asserted, "The mainstream media is cynically using a lot of traumatized teens from Parkland, Fla., in their latest shameful attack on President Trump and the National Rifle Association."
"It's right out of the pages of 'Rules for Radicals,'" complained author Todd Starnes in a passage that sounds like a right-wing version of Mad Libs. "Turning innocent children into propaganda pawns to peddle a fake news narrative."
Dinesh D'Souza
The right-wing activist, convicted felon, and National Review contributor, whose latest book accuses the American left of having roots in Nazism, had some astonishingly unkind words for the Parkland survivors.
"Worst news since their parents told them to get summer jobs," D'Souza commented on a photo of Parkland survivors crying after Florida lawmakers declined to vote on a bill banning assault rifles.
"Adults 1, kids 0," he also wrote in response to the same news.
Ted Nugent
On his Facebook page, which has almost 3.5 million likes, the right-wing activist and music dude posted a link to an article from Natural News—which purports to be "the world's top news source on natural health"—headlined, "It’s all THEATER: Florida high school shooting survivor caught on video rehearsing scripted lines, coached by camera man," which is an aggregation of Wintrich's Gateway Pundit story.
Bill O'Reilly
The former Fox News host, who was fired after multiple allegations of sexual harassment and once paid $32 million to settle a sexual harassment lawsuit, didn't go as far as D'Souza or the Gateway Pundit, but echoed the idea that the surviving students are leftist pawns on Twitter and "debated" the topic on his personal website.
David Clarke
The former Milwaukee sheriff, who was once investigated by the FBI for sending his officers after a guy who got into an argument with him on a plane and on whose watch a mentally ill jail inmate died of dehydration, is another right-wing talking head being an asshole to the teenage mass shooting survivors. According to Media Matters, Clarke was on something called the Joe Pags Show on Monday, which began with host Joe Pagliarulo opining that Gonzalez “a far-lefty propagandist—well, I don’t know that she’s a propagandist... Maybe her parents are, maybe the community is." Later in the program, Clarke said, “My dad would have backhanded me” for “popping off” against an authority figure like President Trump.
It's worth noting that Clarke spent years popping off against Barack Obama, but it's not like calling him—or any of people on this list—out for hypocrisy is particularly useful.
https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/bj5yqw/rush-limbaugh-ted-nugent-parkland
The #1 Trending Video on YouTube Right Now Suggests That a Student From the Parkland Shooting Is a Crisis Actor
A video described as 'DAVID HOGG THE ACTOR….' has made the top of the trending section, another example that YouTube has a conspiracy theory problem.
Emanuel Maiberg
Feb 21 2018, 8:32am
Update: YouTube has removed the video about three hours after this article was first published. It had more than 200,000 views at the time. Other videos from the same YouTube user spreading the same conspiracy theory are still live on YouTube.
A YouTube spokesperson sent us the following statement:
"This video should never have appeared in Trending. Because the video contained footage from an authoritative news source, our system misclassified it. As soon as we became aware of the video, we removed it from Trending and from YouTube for violating our policies. We are working to improve our systems moving forward."
It's a vile conspiracy theory we might expect from the host of Inforwars Alex Jones, but right now it is the number one trending video on YouTube.
The conspiracy theory is that some of the students who are speaking out against the lax gun control laws that enabled the mass shooting that killed 17 of their peers at a Parkland, Florida high school last week are not who they say they are. They are "crisis actors," paid performers funded by familiar boogeymen like George Soros to vilify gun ownership and dismantle the Second Amendment.
This is not true, but it's what the most popular video on YouTube, which at the time of writing has 174,000 views, suggests. In the video, David Hogg, one of the more outspoken Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School students who has made several television appearances since the shooting, is seen in a CBS 2 Los Angeles news report. The report details the events of a video Hogg took and that went viral in 2017. It shows one of Hogg's friends, another teenager, confronting an overzealous lifeguard. Here's the video on CBS's YouTube page, and Hogg's original upload.
The only description on the video is "DAVID HOGG THE ACTOR…." and many of the comments go on to accuse Hogg of being an actor "bought and paid by CNN and George Soros." Mike m, the YouTube user who uploaded this trending video also uploaded a video titled "David Hogg Can't Remember His Lines When Interviewed for Florida school shooting." The description to that video reads: "Ask yourself why is he practicing his lines...??? ???" This user also uploaded videos that cover familiar conspiracy theories like chemtrails and UFOs.
As Hogg explained to CNN, his family moved from California to Florida several years ago and he joined Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School for its TV production program. He took the video of the lifeguard while visiting friends in Los Angeles.
It’s a coincidence that some random person in a local news report will go viral on YouTube and then make national news for vastly different reasons, but it happens. I'm still trying to wrap my brain around the fact that George Lindell, the subject of the autotuned viral video "Reality Hits You Hard Bro" also went viral in 2016 for yelling "Jew-S-A" at a press pen at a Trump rally, but it's true. Life is weird and full of coincidences. Things that seem very unlikely, like, say, landing on the moon, actually happen. It's true.
It's not surprising but still shameful that this trending video is one of many on YouTube. If you watch it, YouTube is likely to offer you videos that claim to show Hogg "forgetting his lines" while speaking to CNN, "SICK secrets about the shooting," and other lies right-wing media uses to muddy the waters around the issue of gun control.
It's only been a month since YouTube was in hot water over its trending videos, which previously highlighted a Logan Paul video that featured a man who took his own life in the thumbnail. As Wired noted at the time, that should have been a moment of reckoning for YouTube, but the trending Hogg video shows that it learned nothing.
Update: When this article was first published the YouTube video suggesting David Hogg is a crisis actor was the number two trending video on YouTube. It is now the number one trending video on YouTube.
https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/mb5p4y/youtube-david-hogg-parkland-shooting-conspiracy-theory
