I understand your point - we are all looking for reliable and credible reviews. Ultimately, this protects both the gentlemen and the ladies involved. However, I would like to raise two points:Hmmm...well, typically when a newbie comes along with great praise, then writes, "...I am not the kiss and tell type" it does raise an eyebrow or two.
Tell or don't tell, that is your right, but take the skepticism along with it.
1) Everyone is new at some point. Although some skepticism is fine, shouldn’t we be trying to encourage more posters rather than discouraging or questioning newbies? Even the most veterans amongst us were newbies at some point. The idea that only veterans have valid reviews defeats the purpose of sharing... Plus, it would seem that the saying « ymmv » applies quite aptly to this industry.
2) Although this is my first review, it does not stand alone. I’ve noticed several other reviewers (newbies and veterans alike on other forums) that have shared likeminded reviews of Kim (over a span of couple of years). I personally tend to place more weight on the entire picture, than any single review, be it from a newbie or a veteran.
As a long time lurker, short time hobbyist and first time poster, I understand the need for some skepticism. But let’s try not to lose focus of the spirit of the forum and encourage newbies, such as myself, to share their experiences rather than to make them feel as though their reviews are questionable or inferior.