While I too question Andersen's ability, he is far better than what they had. Like young players, he could turn into a better goalie than he's shown thus far, as being a the number one goalie is something they need to wrap their head around, knowing that they are it. As long as he's a decent, making the saves that he has to, knowing that the team is behind him and that the players on the ice are there for him, he doesn't have to be the "best" in the NHL. Like the Chicago teams that won the cup, their goal tending wasn't the best, but their team play helped them, as they knew as a team, that they had to help out defensively.
I have been a Kadri supporter through the years, as I have always felt that he was a better player than he's shown. I think he will get better under Babcock, as I think that Mike and the coaching staff have taken the time necessary with him and other players, to develop him into a better player. This year I have seen more maturity out of him and I think we will see a better player in the years to come with him. I'm sure they are doing this, but he really needs to be better on the draw, bringing his percentage up.
Nobody can argue that they need a good number one D-man. Reilly is good and will continue to get better, but they could really use a good number one as they just don't have that guy now. Gardiner is at best a number 3, he's got skill, but he still makes too many mental mistakes in my books.