The point is that any SP who uses this review board as an exclusive means of contact, or uses people from this board as an exclusive means of contact, and does not advertise anywhere else, is not allowed to be reviewed here.
If this girl had an ad in the Citizen or the Sun four weeks ago, and that's how bidbrian got a hold of her initially, fine. That falls within the guidelines of this board. HOWEVER, bidbrian was wanting to be the point of contact for the SP, and she wasn't advertising anywhere else (as he himself admitted).
I guess, to sum it up, the best way to explain it is this... As long as it's Olga from the Sun, or Edna from the Redzone, or Helga from the telephone pole on Bank Street, as long as she has an ad somewhere, in some kind of regularity, reviews are permitted, and even encouraged. Once she becomes Olga, bidbrian's neighbour, or Edna from some chat-line, or Helga who posts on TERB and doesn't advertise anywhere else, we have to draw the line.
And where the line is drawn is entirely up to the administrators of this site.